Comparative Analysis of Hong Kong and Taiwan’s Independence Movements: a case study of identity and politics using social movement theory

Hasselle, Sarah A. (2017) Comparative Analysis of Hong Kong and Taiwan’s Independence Movements: a case study of identity and politics using social movement theory. Undergraduate thesis, under the direction of Noell Wilson from History, University of Mississippi.

Thesis honor college draft Sarah Hasselle.pdf

Download (730kB) | Preview


This thesis is a comparative study on the Taiwanese and Hong Kongese independence movements. Structured by social movement theory, this study focuses on how each movement evolved after a central cause and focuses on the different components of the social movements. This paper also includes an analysis on “national pride” in Taiwan and Hong Kong, tested by using SPSS and data from Asian Barometer. The two independence movements can both be understood through its supporters’ concerns, and in both cases, identity is described as something culturally distinct from the mainland. As for determining “national pride,” my analysis indicates that, in 2010, Taiwanese people with higher social class and people over 50 were more proud to be Taiwanese. As for Hong Kongese people in 2012, males, people over 50 and people with lower social status were more proud to be Chinese. In regards to political opportunity, the Taiwanese independence movement’s opportunity for collective action has contracted on an international scale, but has expanded locally. In Hong Kong, the “failure” of the Umbrella Movement, as well as mainland China’s reaction to the movement, led to the creation of many new pro-independence or pro-localist political parties. By seeking positions in the legislative body, Hong Kong’s independence supporters have attempted to create political opportunity for themselves. In conclusion, this thesis can add to the conversation about sovereignty and democracy in East Asia. This thesis can further shed light to how the Chinese government should conduct relations with both Taiwan and Hong Kong. If gaining Taiwan is still important to the People’s Republic of China, then I suggest that they must first win Hong Kong people’s hearts.

Item Type: Thesis (Undergraduate)
Uncontrolled Keywords: Independence movement, social movement, social movement theory, Taiwan, Hong Kong, mainland China, China
Creators: Hasselle, Sarah A.
Student's Degree Program(s): B.A. in International Studies and Mandarin Chinese
Thesis Advisor: Noell Wilson
Thesis Advisor's Department: History
Institution: University of Mississippi
Subjects: H Social Sciences > H Social Sciences (General)
J Political Science > JQ Political institutions Asia
J Political Science > JZ International relations
Depositing User: Sarah Hasselle
Date Deposited: 11 May 2017 16:37
Last Modified: 11 May 2017 16:37

Actions (login required)

View Item View Item